Shopping for a small outboard motor for your dinghy, jon boat, or fishing skiff? Suzuki and Tohatsu are two of the most trusted names for lightweight, reliable, and easy-to-use engines in the 2.5hp to 20hp range. But how do they compare when it comes to weight, features, starting, and overall value? Here’s a head-to-head review to help you pick the right portable outboard for your needs.
Quick Picks
- Best Overall: Suzuki DF20A – Lightweight for its class, fuel-injected, super quiet, and easy to start.
- Best Budget: Tohatsu MFS9.8 – Dependable, simple, and often the most affordable in the 9.8hp range.
- Best Premium: Suzuki DF15A EFI – Electronic fuel injection, easy tilt, and smooth, quiet operation.
Buyer’s Guide
When choosing a small outboard, keep these factors in mind:
- Weight: Lighter motors are easier to carry and mount, especially if you remove the motor between uses.
- Starting System: Look for easy-pull manual starts or electric start options for hassle-free operation.
- Fuel Efficiency: EFI motors (like Suzuki DF15A/DF20A) use less gas, run smoother, and start easier in all weather.
- Noise & Vibration: Quieter motors mean a more pleasant time on the water—especially at trolling speeds.
- Warranty & Service: Both Suzuki and Tohatsu have solid reliability, but check for local dealer support and warranty terms.
- Price: Tohatsu motors are often a bit more budget-friendly, while Suzuki offers more technology and features in the premium models.
Detailed Product Reviews
1. Suzuki DF20A
Who it’s for: Boaters who want a lightweight, fuel-injected 20hp for dinghies, small skiffs, or as a kicker motor.
- Key Benefits:
- One of the lightest 20hp outboards on the market.
- Electronic fuel injection for smooth, quick starts and efficiency.
- Quiet operation, low vibration, and easy maintenance.
- Pros:
- Weighs under 100 lbs (manual short shaft).
- Available with manual or electric start.
- Very reliable and easy to use.
- Cons:
- Costs more than carbureted competitors.
- Some service tasks may require dealer help.
Final Verdict: A modern, super-light outboard perfect for those who want top performance in a portable package. Check DF20A prices
2. Suzuki DF15A EFI
Who it’s for: Anglers and boaters wanting a fuel-injected 15hp motor with the quietest, smoothest performance available.
- Key Benefits:
- Electronic fuel injection makes cold starts and idling much smoother.
- Lightweight design for easy carrying and mounting.
- Very quiet, low emissions, and great on gas.
- Pros:
- Easy tilt and steering.
- Multiple shaft lengths and controls available.
- Trusted reliability and warranty.
- Cons:
- More expensive than basic models.
- May require authorized service for advanced diagnostics.
Final Verdict: If you want quiet, fuel-injected technology and hassle-free boating, the DF15A is a leader in its class. See DF15A deals
3. Tohatsu MFS9.8
Who it’s for: Boaters looking for maximum value, portability, and a simple, reliable motor for small boats and inflatables.
- Key Benefits:
- Very lightweight—among the lightest in the 9.8hp class (just over 80 lbs).
- Simple manual start, carbureted design means easy DIY maintenance.
- Low price point compared to other name brands.
- Pros:
- Affordable and reliable.
- Available in multiple shaft lengths.
- Good fuel economy for a carbureted model.
- Cons:
- Carbureted engines need occasional cleaning or adjustment.
- Less quiet and smooth than EFI models.
Final Verdict: The MFS9.8 is a simple, lightweight favorite for those on a budget who want no-nonsense reliability. See MFS9.8 pricing
4. Tohatsu MFS20E
Who it’s for: Boaters wanting the highest horsepower in a compact, value-packed outboard.
- Key Benefits:
- Compact and easy to transport for a 20hp engine.
- Electric or manual start options available.
- Very competitive pricing for a 20hp model.
- Pros:
- Modern, fuel-efficient design.
- Lightweight compared to older models.
- Strong warranty and proven Tohatsu reliability.
- Cons:
- Not as quiet as Suzuki’s EFI models.
- Some may find the look and controls basic.
Final Verdict: Great for those who want max power per dollar and easy maintenance in a portable engine. Check MFS20E offers
Comparison Table
| Name | Key Features | Specs / Weight | Price Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| Suzuki DF20A | Light, EFI, quiet, modern | 20hp, EFI, ~97 lbs | Check DF20A prices |
| Suzuki DF15A EFI | EFI, quiet, easy tilt | 15hp, EFI, ~97 lbs | See DF15A deals |
| Tohatsu MFS9.8 | Light, affordable, carbureted | 9.8hp, carb, ~81 lbs | See MFS9.8 pricing |
| Tohatsu MFS20E | High power, compact, value | 20hp, carb/EFi, ~97 lbs | Check MFS20E offers |
FAQ Section
- Q: Which is lighter—Suzuki or Tohatsu?
A: Tohatsu’s 9.8hp is lighter than most Suzuki models, but Suzuki’s new DF15A and DF20A are among the lightest in their class for EFI engines. - Q: Are EFI outboards worth it?
A: Yes, EFI outboards (like Suzuki DF15A/DF20A) are quieter, easier to start, use less fuel, and require less maintenance than carbureted models—though they do cost a bit more up front. - Q: Is Tohatsu reliable?
A: Absolutely—Tohatsu is known for simple, durable motors that last for years, even in tough conditions. Many Mercury small outboards are built by Tohatsu. - Q: Which is quieter—Suzuki or Tohatsu?
A: Suzuki’s EFI models are generally the quietest and smoothest in the small outboard category. - Q: Which brand is best for saltwater?
A: Both brands offer corrosion protection, but regular rinsing and proper maintenance are key for any small outboard used in saltwater.
Conclusion
Suzuki and Tohatsu both deliver dependable, lightweight power for small boats, with strong reputations for reliability and value. Suzuki’s fuel-injected models win for quietness, smooth running, and tech, while Tohatsu leads on price and simple, proven design. Choose based on your need for features, weight, and budget, and you’ll get years of easy, fun boating from either brand.