Deciding between Tohatsu and Mercury outboard motors? You’re not alone. Both brands have a loyal following and offer reliable power for fishing boats, pontoons, and everything in between. But which one is best for your needs—value, performance, features, or support? Here’s a side-by-side review to help you choose confidently for your next repower or new boat build.
Quick Picks
- Best Overall: Mercury 60 EFI FourStroke – Proven performance, smooth operation, and broad dealer network.
- Best Budget: Tohatsu MFS40 – Great value, lighter weight, and straightforward reliability for everyday boating.
- Best Premium: Mercury 115 Pro XS – Top-end speed, extra torque, and premium features for serious anglers and performance fans.
Buyer’s Guide
Consider these points before choosing between Tohatsu and Mercury:
- Performance Needs: What’s your top priority: acceleration, quietness, or fuel economy?
- Boat Size & Weight: Larger boats may benefit from Mercury’s power and trim options, while smaller rigs appreciate Tohatsu’s lighter motors.
- Features: Mercury often packs more digital integration and smart controls, but Tohatsu focuses on simplicity and ease of use.
- Service Network: Mercury has more dealers in many regions, but Tohatsu’s reputation for dependability helps offset a smaller network.
- Warranty: Compare the current warranty length and coverage from each brand.
- Price: Tohatsu is typically more affordable in the same horsepower class.
Detailed Product Reviews
1. Mercury 60 EFI FourStroke
Who it’s for: Boat owners seeking a well-rounded outboard with broad dealer support and smart tech.
- Key Benefits:
- Electronic Fuel Injection for easy starts and crisp throttle.
- Very quiet and smooth at cruise.
- Comprehensive parts and service network.
- Pros:
- Strong brand reputation.
- Good resale value.
- Modern electronics and smart gauge options.
- Cons:
- Priced higher than some competitors.
- Heavier than Tohatsu in some hp classes.
Final Verdict: An excellent choice for boaters wanting a balance of performance, quietness, and support. See current deals
2. Mercury 115 Pro XS
Who it’s for: Performance-minded anglers and owners of larger fishing boats.
- Key Benefits:
- Lightweight for its class, yet delivers strong acceleration and top-end speed.
- Features like SmartCraft digital controls and VesselView compatibility.
- Excellent corrosion protection for saltwater use.
- Pros:
- Premium build and tech.
- Strong dealer and parts network.
- Cons:
- Premium pricing.
- May have more features than casual boaters need.
Final Verdict: Perfect for those who want leading tech, power, and peace of mind. Check latest price
3. Tohatsu MFS40
Who it’s for: Anglers and families seeking an affordable, reliable, lightweight motor for small to mid-size boats.
- Key Benefits:
- Lower weight for easier trailering and better performance on smaller boats.
- Simple, robust engineering for years of hassle-free use.
- Competitive pricing in the 40hp class.
- Pros:
- Very easy to maintain.
- Strong reliability track record.
- Often more affordable than other brands.
- Cons:
- Not as many high-tech features or digital controls.
- Dealer/service network can be smaller in some regions.
Final Verdict: A dependable pick for straightforward boating—great performance without extra cost or complication. View pricing
4. Tohatsu MFS60
Who it’s for: Boaters wanting good power-to-weight for fishing, pontoon, or utility boats.
- Key Benefits:
- Lightweight and fuel-efficient design.
- Simple controls and reliable starts.
- Competitive price for the horsepower.
- Pros:
- Easy to install and handle.
- Good for remote or hard-to-reach fishing spots.
- Cons:
- Fewer dealer options for warranty support.
- More basic dashboard and tech features.
Final Verdict: A smart option for those who want simplicity, value, and dependability. See deals
Comparison Table
| Name | Key Features | Specs / Capacity | Price Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mercury 60 EFI FourStroke | Quiet, tech, dealer support | 60 hp, EFI, multi-purpose | See current deals |
| Mercury 115 Pro XS | Performance, SmartCraft tech | 115 hp, advanced controls | Check latest price |
| Tohatsu MFS40 | Light, simple, affordable | 40 hp, lightweight, basic features | View pricing |
| Tohatsu MFS60 | Power-to-weight, reliability | 60 hp, lightweight, fuel-efficient | See deals |
FAQ Section
- Q: Which brand is more reliable?
A: Both are known for reliability, with Tohatsu often praised for simplicity and durability, while Mercury wins for tech and wide service access. - Q: Are Mercury and Tohatsu motors ever the same?
A: In some lower horsepower ranges, Tohatsu manufactures certain Mercury outboards, but each brand sets its own specs and features for many models. - Q: Which is better for saltwater?
A: Both brands offer corrosion protection, but Mercury’s extensive saltwater lineup may offer extra peace of mind for frequent ocean use. - Q: Which holds its value better?
A: Mercury outboards usually have slightly higher resale value, thanks to brand recognition and wide support, but a well-kept Tohatsu also resells well. - Q: Which is easier to maintain?
A: Tohatsu outboards are renowned for simplicity and ease of maintenance. Mercury’s modern models offer maintenance reminders and digital diagnostics for added convenience.
Conclusion
Tohatsu and Mercury are both excellent outboard brands, each with real strengths. Mercury leads in technology, support, and broad appeal—ideal if you want modern features and strong resale. Tohatsu wins for value, simplicity, and reliability—perfect for boaters who want to keep it straightforward and affordable. Match the engine to your needs, check local dealer support, and you’ll enjoy smooth, reliable power for seasons to come.